TTF Tackles the Money Monster under your bed: Promotion at a Price

"When I was offered a promotion at work, it felt like the culmination of years of hard work and dedication. I had been striving for this next step, chasing the higher salary, increased responsibility, and recognition that comes with climbing the career ladder. But as I reviewed the offer, excitement gave way to confusion and concern. The numbers didn’t add up—this promotion would push me into the 60% tax bracket, leaving me questioning whether the financial rewards truly justified the additional workload and stress.

The offer was everything I had worked for: a title upgrade, more responsibility, and a salary increase from £95,000 to £105,000. It seemed like a no-brainer—until I started reading articles about the 60% tax trap and its impact on people earning over £100,000. Suddenly, my well-deserved promotion feels less like a reward and more like a financial minefield.

So now, I’m honestly rethinking the promotion. These are my three main concerns:

1. More Work, Limited Reward

This new role comes with higher expectations—longer hours, greater responsibility, and the pressure to perform. Yet, the financial gain feels disproportionately small. It’s hard not to feel demotivated knowing the majority of my additional earnings will go straight to HMRC.

2. Loss of Work-Life Balance

The promotion could mean sacrificing evenings and weekends for work, leaving less time for family, friends, and hobbies. Is that trade-off worth it when the financial reward is so heavily taxed?

3. Impact on Future Financial Goals

The reduced take-home pay means I may not achieve my personal savings or investment goals as quickly as I had hoped. It feels counterintuitive — earning more but having less to show for it.

What seemed like a step up suddenly looks like a small leap forward for a much larger effort. This experience has been a wake-up call. For years, I’ve been conditioned to strive for “more” without fully understanding the implications. The 60% tax trap has forced me to rethink what “success” looks like and whether financial gain is the only measure of progress.

I’m still deciding whether to accept the promotion. Help needed! "

Thank you for sharing your story—it highlights a dilemma faced by many professionals navigating career growth in the UK’s current tax environment. Your concerns are valid, and your decision deserves careful consideration. Below, we’ve outlined a balanced perspective to help you weigh the pros and cons of accepting the promotion and making an informed choice.

While the immediate financial implications of entering the 60% tax bracket can be discouraging, focusing solely on the tax impact may obscure the broader benefits of a promotion. Conversely, ignoring the additional workload and lifestyle changes could lead to regret. Here's a deeper look at both sides.

Reasons to Accept the Promotion

Long-Term Career Progression

Promotions aren’t just about the immediate pay rise—they also position you for future opportunities. The added responsibilities and leadership experience may pave the way for even higher-paying roles or career advancements that aren't subject to the same limitations. Over time, this could significantly outweigh the short-term tax impact.

Non-Financial Rewards

A promotion can bring personal satisfaction, recognition, and a stronger sense of achievement. If this role aligns with your long-term goals or fulfills your aspirations, it may be worth considering despite the financial drawbacks.

Opportunities to Mitigate Taxes

Tax-efficient strategies like salary sacrifice for pensions, charitable donations, or timing bonuses can reduce your taxable income and soften the blow of the 60% tax trap. With proper planning, you can make the promotion work financially.

Market Perception

Taking the promotion may demonstrate ambition and capability, positioning you as a strong candidate for future roles—internally or externally. Turning down the role might give an impression of reluctance to take on challenges, which could impact how others perceive your commitment.

Reasons to Decline the Promotion

Lifestyle and Well-Being

If the promotion demands significantly more time, stress, or sacrifices in your personal life, it’s worth questioning whether it aligns with your values. More responsibility doesn’t necessarily mean a better quality of life, and the limited financial rewards in this case could amplify any dissatisfaction.

Net Financial Gain

After factoring in the 60% tax and additional National Insurance, the financial reward may feel insufficient for the extra effort required. If your current role already provides a comfortable balance of income and lifestyle, staying put might be more appealing.

Exploring Alternative Opportunities

If the promotion doesn’t excite you or seems poorly timed, you could focus on building your skills, seeking lateral moves, or exploring opportunities at other organisations that offer better pay or benefits without triggering the 60% tax rate.

Potential for Burnout

Increased workload without proportionate compensation can lead to burnout. If the promotion doesn’t come with adequate support or resources, it may create more frustration than fulfillment.

Key Questions to Ask Yourself

What Are My Long-Term Career Goals? Does this promotion align with where I see myself in 5–10 years? Is it a stepping stone to something I truly want?

Can I Handle the Increased Responsibility? Will I have the time, energy, and support to manage the new role effectively without compromising my personal life?

Is the Financial Gain Worth It? Am I comfortable with the limited take-home pay after taxes, given the extra effort required?

What Tax-Efficient Strategies Can I Use? Have I consulted with a financial advisor to explore ways to maximise the benefits of this promotion while minimising the tax impact?

Balanced Advice

Reflect on your career, personal goals, and lifestyle preferences. If this promotion aligns with your aspirations and you’re confident you can manage the additional workload, the long-term benefits may outweigh the short-term tax frustrations.

Seek Financial Advice

A tax advisor can help you strategise to reduce the impact of the 60% tax bracket. With tools like salary sacrifice or charitable giving, you can make the promotion more financially rewarding.

Consider Negotiating

If you’re on the fence, consider discussing the terms with your employer. You might negotiate non-financial perks like flexible hours, additional leave, or a higher employer pension contribution, which could offset the stress or tax burden.

Be Patient

If the promotion doesn’t feel right now, it’s okay to decline and wait for a better opportunity. Career growth isn’t always linear, and a pause at this stage might allow you to grow in ways that make the next step more rewarding.

Accepting or declining a promotion is a deeply personal decision that depends on your goals, values, and circumstances. There’s no right or wrong choice—it’s about finding what’s best for you. Whatever you decide, take comfort in knowing that your hard work and dedication are already paying off, and there will always be more opportunities to grow and succeed.

If you choose to move forward, arm yourself with strategies to maximise your financial and personal rewards. If you decide to stay where you are, know that stepping back to reflect is sometimes the smartest step forward.

Capital Gains Tax Expertise: The Tax Faculty LLP Managing Partner Charles Tateson Named UK Capital Gains Tax Advisor of the Year 2023

The Finance Monthly Taxation Awards recognises the achievements of tax professionals from around the globe.

Winning such an award is no small feat. It is a reflection of hard work, extensive knowledge, and an ability to navigate the intricacies of the UK tax system.

Read more about Charles and the award here.

Contact Us

Contact us today on freephone 0800 0016 878 for a free consultation on all tax issues, or fill out the handy form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Alternatively, you can email us at info@thetaxfaculty.co.uk or complete the form below.

(Please note, non-UK callers may need to call 0207 101 3845 if your line cannot connect to our 0800 number)

Feel free to contact us through WhatsApp - we accept calls and messages.

Simply click the WhatsApp button below: